Main Street Tavern

Nestled in the heart of Broken Arrow, Main Street Tavern invites those seeking a vibrant and satisfying dining experience that masterfully blends the warmth of a gastropub with the lively spirit of a sports and wine bar. This local favorite, located at 200 S Main St, crafts a welcoming atmosphere perfect for everything from casual family dinners to festive gatherings with friends.

The menu at Main Street Tavern is a delightful tour through American comfort food, elevated with creative twists and fresh, bold flavors. Signature dishes like the MST Nachos pile on melty cheese, fresh toppings, and a perfect balance of savory and spice that practically melts on your tongue. The Beer Battered Mozzarella offers a crispy, golden bite with a creamy, stringy center pairing beautifully with their house-made dips.

For those craving hearty meals, the Meatloaf Sliders—nestled on mini sourdough rolls with applewood smoked bacon and melted provolone—deliver a nostalgic depth that will soothe any comfort food craving. The Sirloin Steak is a standout, featuring USDA Choice beef brushed with a rich tavern steak butter, served alongside silky garlic mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables that add a fresh, earthy touch. If you're looking for an indulgently creamy option, the Main Street Mac & Cheese and the Seafood Macaroni Cheese provide both richness and satisfying texture.

Adding variety and a bit of Southern charm, the Chicken Pot Pie brings flaky crust and savory filling with house-seasoned chicken and vegetables. The Shrimp & Grits elevate this Southern classic with tender shrimp resting on a bed of creamy, perfectly seasoned grits. For those lighter moments, the Cobb Salad offers a refreshing combination of greens, crisp bacon, avocado, and eggs with a zingy dressing.

Main Street Tavern’s beverage offerings complement its hearty fare nicely, boasting everything from classic sodas and freshly brewed teas to inventive cocktails and an array of cider options, ideal for unwinding after a busy day. The friendly, down-to-earth staff, frequently praised by customers like Chris Edwards and Carlette Baum, ensure attentive and personalized service that adds warmth to every meal. Notably, servers like Miranda and Rebel have been highlighted for making dining out feel like a true occasion—efficient, personable, and genuinely caring.

The atmosphere buzzes with energy but never overwhelms, striking a balance between lively and relaxed. Whether you’re gathered around watching the game at the bar or enjoying a cozy dinner in one of their comfortable seating areas, Main Street Tavern makes you feel part of the community. Its spacious layout is perfect for large groups or intimate dinners alike, allowing for easy conversation without sacrificing the vibrant ambiance.

Reviewers consistently mention the memorable combination of great food, thoughtful service, and inviting environment. There’s a sense that this tavern is more than just a place to eat—it’s a place where great memories are made over fantastic food, carefully crafted drinks, and genuine hospitality. From the tangy kick of the Buffalo Wings in Jalapeno Barbeque Sauce to the comforting indulgence of the Classic Fish & Chips, every bite signals a little celebration of flavor.

If you find yourself in Broken Arrow craving hearty, flavorful dishes served with care and a smile, Main Street Tavern promises a dining experience that feels both familiar and exciting. It’s where local charm meets culinary creativity, designed to satisfy cravings and create moments worth savoring.